Thursday, April 26th, 2007

Hysterectomy by Robot?

Gosh, just when I thought that robots that vacuum (like Roomba) were the ultimate in robotic technology….

Take a look at this: a 1,200-pound, million dollar robot that assists at laparoscopic hysterectomies.

Out of 600,000 hysterectomies performed each year in the U.S., just one out of 10 are laparoscopic-assisted vaginal hysterectomies (LAVH) — a much less invasive procedure than the TAH (total abdominal hysterectomy) performed on the majority of patients.

One of the key reasons why more women don’t receive the less invasive procedure is because of a long and difficult learning curve for surgeons.

The da Vinci(R) Surgical System hopes to remedy that difficulty. Robot-assisted surgery offers surgeons a way to perform finely controlled movements, while operating through a magnified 3-D view of the surgery site.

The robot’s camera and instruments are inserted in three or four inch-long slits in the abdomen (compared to a single 6-7-inch opening for a TAH). Doctors say that using the system is “like playing a video game.”

According to the system’s manufacturer, potential patient benefits include:

  • Shorter hospital stay
  • Less pain and scarring
  • Less risk of wound infection
  • Less blood loss and fewer transfusions
  • Faster recovery
  • Quicker return to normal activities

You can watch short videos on the system here, here and here.

So what do you think? Does robotic surgery make sense to you?

 


You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

11 Responses

May 8, 2007
Karen

Well, I hope it works, I’m scheduled for one next week! (May 15th)!!1

I’m a little nervous!


May 9, 2007
admin

Hey again, Karen. See your other Comment for my reply about “Recovery.”

Cheers,
Sheila


May 12, 2007
Sharon

I had a DaVinci hysterectomy on April 5 (5 weeks ago). I felt so good, I went back to work after three weeks. I would recommend it to anyone who has this offered to them by their doctor.


May 20, 2007
Angela

I had my robotic hysterectomy 1 week ago and would highly recommend it to anyone. I was out of the hospital the next morning. I would compare my recovery to the lap appy I had a year ago. I feel great!!!


May 23, 2007
Karen

It was a week yesterday since my Da vinci surgery. I’m not saying that 7 days is the magic number, but WOW - I feel great! Amazingly so. I highly reoommend this procedure - just make sure your surgeon is trained :).

BTW Sheila, thanks for the link to Recovery!!
Karen


May 28, 2007
admin

You’re most welcome, Karen. And what great news that you’re doing so well! Thanks for letting us all know your experiences with Da Vinci. I am quite jealous. ;-)

The system is very expensive, so it will be a while before it is widely available, but this is definitely a postive trend.

Cheers,
Sheila


November 21, 2007
Karla

I had a DaVinci hysterectomy, including ovaries removed, at Virginia Mason (Seattle) in 30 days ago. my experience was good. One night in the hospital. But, I’m in my 40s, relatively fit and healthy, and I was overly optimistic on what I could do. This is still major surgery! A week after I flew home (could have driven, but glad not to). Three weeks after I headed off to a meeting, with travel involving planes and a road trip. That all went well so I came home and dug into moving some boxes - today I am laid up with internal discomforts that tells me I overdid it.

The one thing I would ask to have done differently: my surgeon glued the four incisions on my abdomen. They all came apart from simple movement and left fairly deep open wounds. The one with the glue that lasted longest revealed itself last week and now is considerably behind the others in healing. I would ask for disolving sutures or other more secure option.


April 20, 2008
Mark R. Preston, MD

For all of you women out there who are contemplating hysterectomy, you should know that one does not need a robot to perform minimally invasive hysterectomy. Laparoscopic hysterectomies have been performed without robots for over 15 years and vaginal hysterectomies for longer than that. The amount of pain and recovery time is no different with and without a robot. In fact, for a routine laparoscopic hysterectomy, one is likely to have a longer surgery with more incisions with a robot than without.

The use of the da Vinci for routine gynecologic procedures is purely marketing driven–the hospitals need to recoup the money they paid for the machine and physicians see it as a way to woo new patients dazzled by the technology. There is nothing wrong, medically, with doing a hysterectomy with the da Vinci, but it adds unnecessary costs while providing no benefit to the patient. All of the benefits claimed by the manufacturer of the da Vinci robot are true also of vaginal hysterectomy and laparoscopic hysterectomy without the robot. It is true that laparoscopic hysterectomy is technically somewhat challenging, but if your surgeon isn’t technically skilled enough to do this surgery without the robot, then you might want to think twice as to whether he/she is the surgeon you want operating on you. There are plenty of skilled gynecologic surgeons who do laparoscopic hysterectomy without the robot.

Certain conditions do sometimes warrant the utilizing the technical advantages one can gain with the robot. Some of these are: severe endometriosis, tubal reanastamosis, sacrocolpopexy, cancer cases where lymph node dissection may be needed. Otherwise, straight laparoscopic of vaginal hysterectomy will give you the same benefits of the robot, but with a quicker surgery at less cost to the health care system.

Even without the robot, over 90% of the hysterectomies I perform are done vaginally or laparoscopically, without a large abdominal incision, and my patients get the same benefits as the patients above. I do not currently perform robotic-assisted surgery, but I am planning to learn to, as I do perform other technically difficult surgeries where it may have an advantage.

My take away is that you shouldn’t switch doctors just because yours doesn’t do robotic hysterectomies. However, you should look for a doctor who can do your hysterectomy vaginally or laparoscopically. Unless you have cancer or your uterus is larger than a 4-5 month pregnancy, there is no reason you need to have an old-fashioned abdominal hysterectomy.


January 29, 2009
Denise

I am having the Da Vinci in Febuary on teh 16th to be exact I was really glad to have found this on the web I was scared at first but it sounds like this will probably be one of the less avasive surgery’s that I ever had before.I will let you all know how it goes.Fingers crossed..


March 28, 2009
michelle

I will have a abdom hysterectomy on april 7 th pretty scared but hope it will cure my pain.


April 9, 2009
Sheila

Saying a little prayer that all went well for you, Michelle!

Best, Sheila